Hiring your first employee is an exciting milestone! Now it’s time to set up payroll, which means completing and keeping track of tax forms, withholdings, deposits, and deadlines. All of this can be overwhelming if you don’t know where to start or how to put a payroll system in place. To help you figure it out, I’ll walk you through all of the steps small business owners should take to set up payroll, and I’ll also tell you how to avoid common payroll mistakes.
What is payroll, and does my small business really need it?
Payroll is how you pay employees for their work, but it’s more than just writing a check or setting up a direct deposit. It also includes calculating wages, withholding applicable taxes, paying employer payroll taxes, and filing required tax forms.
If you hire someone as an employee, then you really can’t just write them a check or send them a Venmo at the end of each week or month and call that payroll. You have legal responsibilities you must fulfill as an employer.
For example, even if you only hire 1 part-time employee, you’ll need to:
- Track their hours,
- Calculate their gross wages,
- Withhold taxes,
- Pay the employee their net wages,
- Pay your employer’s share of payroll taxes,
- Deposit withheld taxes with the IRS,
- File required payroll tax returns, and
- Provide your employee with a W-2 at the end of the year.
Do I need payroll if I’m a sole proprietor or single-member LLC?
This is one of the most common questions I get from new business owners. If you’re a sole proprietor or a single-member LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship, you don’t need to put yourself on payroll. Instead, you pay yourself through owner withdrawals, which are also called owner’s draws.
With these business entity types, if your business earns $8,000 for the month, and you transfer $3,000 from your business checking account to your personal account, that transfer isn’t considered a paycheck, so you’re taxed on the full $8,000. This is because the IRS treats your business as a “disregarded entity,” so you are taxed on 100% of the business’ net profit regardless of whether you leave the money in your business account or draw it out.
However, if your business is taxed as an S-Corporation, there are different rules. You’ll need to pay yourself a reasonable compensation, which typically is done through payroll just like it is with any W-2 employee, even if the owner takes distributions from the business as well.
If you’re unsure whether you should be paying yourself through payroll, it’s always best to check with your CPA before setting anything up.
Should I hire an employee or an independent contractor?
Let’s start from the top. You won’t know if you even need to set up payroll until you determine whether the person you’re hiring is actually an employee. What else could they be? Well, depending on the working relationship you have with one another, they may be an independent contractor instead.
The distinction between employee and independent contractor is very important because employees are treated differently for tax purposes.
In simple terms, if you’re hiring an employee, then you’ll need to set up payroll, withhold payroll taxes, pay your part of Social Security and Medicare taxes for them, and provide them with a W-2.
On the other hand, if you’re hiring an independent contractor, you may need to issue them a Form 1099-NEC, but you won’t need to withhold taxes or pay employment taxes related to paying them.
Please understand that even though it seems easier to just call your employee a contractor and avoid all of the added tax hassle and forms, you can’t just choose to classify them that way because it’s easier or less expensive.
During an audit, the IRS will examine the working relationship between the business and independent contractors. If they decide that a business misclassified an employee as an independent contractor, then in addition to owing at least part of the back taxes that the business should have paid, the business could also be on the hook for paying penalties for misclassified wages and unfiled tax forms.
If the misclassification is found to have been done intentionally, then the business could also be held accountable for paying the income taxes that the employee should have paid.
In some circumstances, the business owner could also face criminal charges and be hit with other penalties, jail time, or lawsuits, even if the misclassification wasn’t intentional.
What do I need to do to set up payroll for a small business?
Before cutting your first paycheck, you’ll want to take care of a few important things:
- Get an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS.
- Research and register for applicable state employer accounts for things like unemployment insurance, state income tax withholding, local payroll taxes, and new-hire reporting requirements.
- Open a business bank account if you haven’t already (really hoping you have!).
- Choose a payroll system; you can DIY or hire a payroll service.
- Ask the employee to complete a Form W-4.
How do I calculate an employee’s paycheck?
Let’s walk through an example so you can see how this calculation is done and who pays what.
In the example below, the employee earns $20 per hour and works 40 hours during a 2-week pay period. The employee’s filing status is single, they only have 1 job, and they haven’t requested any additional withholdings or adjustments on their Form W-4
An important note here is that the amount of federal income tax withheld is determined by using the information that the employee entered on their Form W-4. To make the calculation, you’ll use the IRS withholding tables, which take into account the employee’s filing status, pay frequency, and other information from their Form W-4.
Something else to keep in mind here is that this example doesn’t include state income tax, health insurance premiums, retirement contributions, or any other deductions or withholdings that may apply.
Additionally, as the employer, you’ll still need to pay employment taxes. These taxes are the employer’s share of the Social Security and Medicare taxes (FICA), federal unemployment tax (FUTA), and any other costs for state unemployment taxes, workers’ compensation insurance, and other employee benefits.
What are the most common payroll mistakes small business owners make?
Even organized business owners can make mistakes when they set up payroll for the first time. Here are a few things you can watch out for to avoid making mistakes:
- Misclassifying employees as contractors.
- Forgetting about employer payroll taxes.
- Not making payroll tax deposits on time.
- Mixing business and personal accounts.
- Not keeping accurate payroll records.
- Forgetting about state payroll or employment-related requirements.
- Not asking for help.
Abridged by Amy
Payroll is one of those areas of small business finances that seems like it should be simple, but in reality, it’s tied to lots of requirements, forms, and calculations. If you’re just getting started with payroll, or if you’re tired of feeling overwhelmed by it, then I encourage you to think about outsourcing this part of your business. Or at the very least, consult a CPA so you can make sure you’re on the right path.
Remember that the important steps for setting up payroll are: properly classify your workers, register for the employer accounts you need, collect the needed forms from your employees, and keep track of your tax-related deadlines.
Oftentimes, what makes the biggest difference to your bottom line and to your sanity is getting a system that works for your business and finding the right professionals to help you when you need them.
After all, knowing when to ask for help and understanding what is (and isn’t) worth your time and effort is the ultimate boss move.